4 in 10 employers penalized in 2026 weren’t actually operating

What 1,811 immigration penalty records show. Our compliance lookup collects the immigration penalties and licence restrictions published by the federal government, Ontario, Saskatchewan and Québec. We counted who was penalized, why, and by how much.

Published November 14, 2026

In one sentence

Our compliance lookup holds 1,811 immigration penalty and licence-restriction records published by the federal government, Ontario, Saskatchewan and Québec (as of November 13, 2026). Federal employer penalties have reached 336 so far this year, the most in any year on record, with about $12.25 million in fines. Four in ten of them (137) list among their reasons that the employer was not actively engaged in the business the foreign worker was hired for, up from 3% in 2023. On Ontario’s nominee program list, 55 records concern applicants themselves, and every one of them was banned from applying for 3 to 5 years.

1. Federal employer penalties: a record year, and a jump in “not actively engaged”

IRCC publishes employers found non-compliant under the Temporary Foreign Worker Program and the International Mobility Program, with a reason number, the penalty and whether they can still hire.[1] The list now has 1,556 records covering about 1,540 differently named employers; most appear only once.

Federal employer penalties by decision year

Each bar is the employer records IRCC published with a reason that year; 2026 runs to November 6.

  • Reasons include “not actively engaged in the business”
  • Other reasons
010020030040020192020202120222023202420252026*

Data: IRCC list of non-compliant employers, collected by iRadar on Nov 13, 2026.

  • 336 records this year, the most on record. There were 263 in 2025, and the previous high was 259 in 2021. This year’s count will still rise: it only covers decisions up to November 6, and IRCC publishes with a delay.
  • “Not actively engaged” went from 3% to 41%. It ran between 3% and 9% a year from 2019 to 2023, then 24% in 2024, 21% in 2025 and 41% this year (137 of 336). In IRCC’s words, the employer was not actively engaged in the business that the foreign national was hired to work for.[1] That does not mean the company does not exist, but the business behind the job was not really running.
  • Fines are getting larger. Total fines were about $3.79 million in 2024, $8.73 million in 2025 and about $12.25 million so far this year. Records citing “not actively engaged” had a median fine of $30,000 this year, against a median of about $7,600 for all records.
Total federal employer fines by decision year

Canadian dollars. 2026 runs to November 6.

$0$2.0M$4.0M$6.0M$8.0M$10.0M$12.0M$14.0M20192020202120222023202420252026*

Data: IRCC list of non-compliant employers, collected by iRadar on Nov 13, 2026.

2. The most common reasons

IRCC’s list only shows reason numbers, and so do the record pages in our compliance lookup. These are the eight most common; the number in front is the reason number you will see on a record. The 56 records for incidents before the December 2015 rules have no reason and are excluded.

The 8 most common reasons

Share of the 1,500 records with a published reason. A record can have several reasons, so shares add up to more than 100%.

  • 6 · Did not give the inspector the documents asked for942 · 62.8%
  • 9 · Pay or conditions worse than the job offer, or a different job507 · 33.8%
  • 15 · Not actively engaged in the business the worker was hired for283 · 18.9%
  • 8 · Broke hiring and recruitment laws139 · 9.3%
  • 2 · Did not keep documents showing compliance124 · 8.3%
  • 4 · Could not show the LMIA job description was accurate100 · 6.7%
  • 5 · Did not meet the inspector to answer questions83 · 5.5%
  • 17 · Did not do enough to prevent abuse or reprisal at work56 · 3.7%

Data: IRCC list of non-compliant employers, collected by iRadar on Nov 13, 2026.

The official wording of all 30 reasons is on IRCC’s page.[1]

3. How much, and can they still hire

The 1,500 records with a fine have a median of about $7,600; the largest is $1 million, and the total since 2016 is about $31.5 million.

Fine per record

The 1,500 records with a fine, in Canadian dollars.

  • $1,000 or less318
  • $1,000–5,000386
  • $5,000–20,000456
  • $20,000–100,000274
  • Over $100,00066

Data: IRCC list of non-compliant employers, collected by iRadar on Nov 13, 2026.

Half the records are currently barred from hiring. Of the 757 marked “Ineligible”, 653 are for an unpaid penalty; bans with an end date run from 1 to 10 years, most often 5.

Can these employers still hire foreign workers?

Official status of every record on the federal list.

Eligible 799Ineligible: unpaid penalty 653Ineligible: ban with an end date 87Ineligible: no end date given 171,556all records
  • Eligible799 · 51%
  • Ineligible: unpaid penalty653 · 42%
  • Ineligible: ban with an end date87 · 6%
  • Ineligible: no end date given17 · 1%

Data: IRCC list of non-compliant employers, collected by iRadar on Nov 13, 2026.

So if an employer is on the list, check its official status: a penalized employer that has paid can hire again; one marked “Ineligible” cannot for now.

4. Where these employers are

B.C. has more records than Ontario, close to three in ten. These are raw counts, though, not adjusted for how many foreign workers each province employs.

By the employer’s province

By published address; darker means more records.

  • 200+
  • 50–199
  • 10–49
  • 1–9
  • 0
AB 316BC 461MB 53NB 31NL 8NS 36NT 1NU 3ON 393PE 0QC 161SK 69YT 4BC461AB316SK69MB53ON393QC161YT4NT1NU3NL8NB31NS36PE0

Another 20 records have no published address and are not on the map.

Data: IRCC list of non-compliant employers, collected by iRadar on Nov 13, 2026.

5. Ontario’s nominee program: applicants are penalized too

Ontario has published 128 penalties under its nominee program (OINP), with decisions from December 2021 to December 2025; 80 of them are from 2025 alone.[2][3]

Ontario’s nominee program: who was penalized, and why

Ontario’s 128 OINP penalties, by subject and reason.

  • Inaccurate or misleading information
  • Did not provide information as required
  • Acted as a representative without a licence
  • Did not meet the conditions of the approval
29
24
2
Applicants (55)
23
13
8
Representatives (consultants etc.) (44)
23
6
Employers (29)

Data: Ontario Data Catalogue, contraventions dataset, collected by iRadar on Nov 13, 2026.

  • Applicants, 55: all bans, 3 years (47) or 5 years (8).
  • Representatives (consultants etc.), 44: 43 fines from $2,000 to $150,000, median $5,000; 8 of them acted as representatives without a licence.
  • Employers, 29: 28 fines, mostly $2,000; one five-year ban.

A banned applicant cannot apply to the OINP while the ban lasts.[2] In 24 of these cases, the reason was simply not answering an OINP letter as required.

6. Saskatchewan and Québec

  • Saskatchewan: 81 investigation outcomes, 76 of them employers. Most are cancellations (38) or suspensions (30) of a registration certificate or licence, plus 13 refused renewals; 43 are from 2025.[4]
  • Québec: 46 immigration consultants have had their recognition revoked. The list gives no dates or reasons, so we show it as a licence status, separate from penalty records.[5]

7. How to use this

  • Before accepting a job offer or an LMIA, search the employer. Enter the company or trading name in the compliance lookup. If it is there, check the official status first, then look up the reason numbers in the table in section 2.
  • Before paying someone to handle your application, check their licence. Eight of Ontario’s records are people who acted as representatives without a licence. Consultant licences are on the CICC public register, which our lookup does not cover yet.[6] IRCC says its own list of penalized representatives is expected in 2027.[7]
  • If the OINP writes to ask for information, answer it as requested.
  • No result does not mean no problem. The lists only include published penalties, and B.C.’s own violations list is not in our lookup yet.

Method and sources

  • Data: the public snapshot of our compliance lookup, collected on November 13, 2026, with all four sources collected successfully: federal 1,556 records, Ontario 128, Saskatchewan 81, Québec 46.
  • Records are not employers: we count records on the official lists. One employer can have several, and the same name is not always the same business.
  • Years: by the official decision date. 2026 only includes decisions up to November 6.
  • Reason shares: the denominator is records with a published reason; the 56 records for incidents before December 1, 2015 have no reason and are excluded. The reason summaries are ours, based on IRCC’s wording.
  • Addresses: each record counts once in every province where it has a published address.

Sources

  1. IRCC: Employers who have been found non-compliant, with reasons: https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/work-canada/employers-non-compliant.html
  2. Ontario: Contraventions of the Ontario Immigration Act, 2015 and why orders were issued: https://www.ontario.ca/page/contraventions-ontario-immigration-act-2015-andor-its-regulations-and-how-report-suspected
  3. Ontario Data Catalogue: contraventions dataset: https://data.ontario.ca/en/dataset/contraventions-of-the-ontario-immigration-act-2015-and-or-its-regulations
  4. Saskatchewan: Violations and investigation outcomes: https://www.saskatchewan.ca/residents/moving-to-saskatchewan/live-in-saskatchewan/by-immigrating/protections-for-immigrants-and-foreign-workers/violations-and-investigation-outcomes
  5. Québec: Immigration consultants whose recognition has been revoked: https://www.quebec.ca/immigration/consultants-immigration/trouver-consultant/liste-des-consultantes-et-consultants-en-immigration-dont-la-reconnaissance-de-titre-a-ete-revoquee
  6. CICC: public register of licensed consultants: https://register.college-ic.ca/
  7. IRCC: New penalties for fraudulent and unauthorized immigration and citizenship representatives (Oct 28, 2026): https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/news/2026/10/new-penalties-for-fraudulent-and-unauthorized-immigration-and-citizenship-representatives.html

These figures are iRadar’s own counts of official public records. They do not represent the views of any government and are not legal or immigration advice. The lists only include penalties that have been published, and the same name does not always mean the same company or person.

Spotted a technical or content problem? Tell us on the feedback page →